Shanawdithit: The Last of the Beothuk
In the winter of 1828, in a modest house in St. John’s, Newfoundland, a young woman sat at a table with paper and pencil and did something no one else on earth could do. She drew the shape of her people’s dwellings, mapped the rivers and lakes they had hunted, sketched the spirits they believed in, and set down, scene by scene, the story of how they had been hunted to the edge of existence. Her name was Shanawdithit. The settlers called her Nancy April. She was, so far as anyone has ever been able to establish, the last living member of the Beothuk — the Indigenous nation of Newfoundland — and she knew it. When tuberculosis killed her the following June, a whole people, with its language, its beliefs and its memory, went out of the world in a single breath.
The people who painted themselves red
The Beothuk had lived on the island of Newfoundland for centuries before Europeans came. They were hunters and gatherers who moved with the seasons between the coast and the interior, taking caribou, salmon, seals and seabirds, and they had a striking custom that would follow them into history: they coated their bodies, their tools, their canoes and even their dead in a paste of red ochre. To the first European fishermen who glimpsed them, this made them the “Red Indians” — a phrase that would later spread, wrongly, across a whole continent. But the ochre was theirs first, a mark of belonging and ritual worn by a people who wanted little to do with the strangers arriving on their shores.
The strangers who would not leave
From the 1500s onward, European ships came each summer to fish the astonishing cod grounds off Newfoundland, drying their catch on the very beaches the Beothuk depended on. Unlike many Indigenous nations, the Beothuk chose not to trade. They withdrew instead, melting into the forests of the interior whenever the ships appeared, taking iron nails and traps when they could but avoiding the newcomers themselves. For a time the strategy of avoidance worked. But the fishing stations became year-round settlements, and the settlers pushed inland up the salmon rivers and out to the sealing grounds — the exact places the Beothuk needed to survive. A people who lived by the coast in summer were slowly, deliberately locked out of it.
A war without a name
What followed was less a war than a squeezing. Cut off from the sea’s food and driven back toward the barren interior, the Beothuk began to starve. Tuberculosis and other imported diseases, against which they had no defence, tore through a population already weakening. And there was blood: settlers and Beothuk raided one another, and there are ugly, well-attested accounts of trappers shooting Beothuk on sight, treating human beings as vermin to be cleared from the land. There were no great battles and no formal declaration — only a steady, grinding disappearance that the colonial authorities noticed too late and did far too little to stop. By the early 1800s only a handful of Beothuk were thought to remain, huddled around the great inland water the settlers renamed Red Indian Lake.
The taking of Demasduit
In March 1819, a party of settlers led by the furrier John Peyton Jr. went up to the lake, ostensibly to recover stolen property and — some hoped — to open friendly contact at last. Instead they seized a young Beothuk woman named Demasduit, Shanawdithit’s aunt. Her husband, a tall and respected man remembered as Nonosbawsut, came after them to win her back and was shot dead on the ice. Demasduit, who had a newborn child, was carried off to the settlements and renamed Mary March for the month of her capture. She was shown around, sketched, and then, sick with tuberculosis, sent back toward her people — only to die on the way in early 1820, never having reached them. It was the same colonial machinery of capture and display that swallowed other lone figures whole, like the enigmatic boy who appeared from nowhere in a German town and became a curiosity for the powerful.
The last three
Four years later, in the spring of 1823, three starving Beothuk women gave themselves up near Badger Bay: a mother and her two daughters. One of the daughters was Shanawdithit. The mother and the other daughter died of tuberculosis within weeks. Shanawdithit, then in her early twenties, was taken into the household of John Peyton Jr. — the very man who had led the raid that killed her uncle — where she lived for five years as a servant under the name Nancy April, doing domestic work for the family. She was, in all likelihood, already the last of her nation, though no one could yet be certain how completely her people had vanished into the forests and the graves.
The drawings that saved a world
In 1828 a Scottish-born explorer named William Epps Cormack, who had walked clear across the interior of Newfoundland searching in vain for surviving Beothuk, founded a society to study and — he told himself — help them. He brought Shanawdithit to St. John’s, and there, in the last months of her life, she gave history its one true window into her people. She could sketch beautifully. On sheet after sheet she drew the conical bark mamateeks they lived in, their canoes and weapons, their storehouses and spirit figures, and she mapped the country of the Beothuk. Most piercingly, she drew the events themselves: the capture of her aunt Demasduit, the death of Nonosbawsut, the movements of the last survivors. She gave Cormack vocabulary and songs, fragments of a language otherwise lost forever. Almost everything the modern world knows from the inside about Beothuk life comes from the hand of this one dying woman — a sole witness preserving an entire vanished people, much as history sometimes leaves us a single strange survivor as the only living link to a world we can no longer reach.
The last of the Beothuk
Shanawdithit died of tuberculosis in St. John’s on 6 June 1829. She was perhaps twenty-eight. With her, the Beothuk people — as a living nation with its own tongue and its own memory of itself — came to an end. In a final indignity, her skull was removed and shipped to the Royal College of Surgeons in London as a specimen; it was destroyed there more than a century later in the German bombing of the Second World War, so that not even her remains were left to rest. For generations she was spoken of simply as “the last of the Red Indians,” a melancholy footnote, another people the wider world managed to forget almost as soon as it had erased them — the way whole communities could vanish and go unmourned, like the thousands lost in a disaster the world barely noticed.
The story is not quite as clean as “extinction,” and that matters. Some Beothuk had almost certainly moved among or intermarried with the Mi’kmaq of Newfoundland and the Innu of Labrador before the end, and there are people today who carry that ancestry and that memory forward. In 2020, after long campaigning, the stolen remains of Demasduit and Nonosbawsut were finally returned from a museum in Scotland to Newfoundland, brought home nearly two hundred years after they were taken. It was a small act of repair against an immense wrong.
What stays with you is the picture of that young woman at the table in St. John’s, drawing as fast as her failing lungs would let her. She had lost her aunt, her uncle, her mother, her sister and, one by one, everyone else who had ever spoken her language or known her gods. She had every reason to give the strangers nothing. Instead she gave them everything she could remember, so that a people the world was busy forgetting would not disappear completely — so that we would at least have to know their names. The Beothuk are gone. Because of Shanawdithit, they are not silent.
Sources & further reading:
More from the archive
- The Black Donnellys
- The Bear River Massacre: The Deadliest Day for Native Americans That America Forgot
- The Dance of Death: The Sinking of the SS Mendi and the Men History Forgot